San andreas started out decently, but quickly gave in to just about every single hollywood cliche in the books. San andreas filmmakers disregarded science advice, expert. As an earth scientist and a science educator, i cringed when i saw, many months ago, a trailer for the new film san andreas. The new film san andreas, starring dwayne the rock johnson, is an. The nostromo is a snarl of leaking hydraulic lines, cramped eating. May 29, 2015 basically, san andreas is scientifically accurate when it can be and not accurate when the plot of the film needs something specific to happen. But san andreas also suggests you dont need to look like a former professional wrestler to be a hero. Usgs finds fault with the authenticity of san andreas. San andreas is a 2015 american disaster film directed by brad peyton and written by carlton cuse, with andre fabrizio and jeremy passmore receiving story credit. May 24, 2015 the san andreas system in northern california consists of five major branches with an overall length of about 1,25o miles.
In the film, an earthquake destroys the hoover dam. How san andreas is boosting californias earthquake industry. May 28, 2015 the new dwayne johnson movie san andreas is a heartpumping thrill ride, a throwback to the peopleinperil disaster flicks that irwin allen made in the 1970s but with stateoftheart special. Usgs finds fault with the authenticity of san andreas trailers. They wanted to create a sciencebased crisis scenario that can be used for preparedness drills. San andreas came out this weekend, and it is for sure the next awesomely terrible disaster flick. The new dwayne johnson movie san andreas is a heartpumping thrill ride, a throwback to the peopleinperil disaster flicks that irwin allen made in the 1970s but with stateoftheart special. Could the earthquake that happened in the san andreas movie happen in real life. Upon its first week of release on home media in the u. It indicates a way to close an interaction, or dismiss a notification. Seismologist lucile jones discusses how accurate or not the plot of this.
The new movie san andreas, starring dwayne johnson better. Bad acting, a disaster movie love story, and worst of all cringeworthy exposition. Given the size and geometry of the faults, the odds of an earthquake above magnitude 8. Rays daughter, blake, is a brave, resourceful figure in her own rightusing lessons from her dad and a wealth of common sense to stay alive and a step ahead of disaster. Lucy jones says that if you adjust the magnitudes for whats possible along the real san andreas fault, the movie s triggering pattern is plausible.
Just how much did the creators of twister get right and wrong the upcoming storm chasing thriller into the storm has the potential to be this. Sep 28, 2015 the martian is hitting cinemas right about now, and already it is being heralded as one of the most scientifically accurate scifi films of all time. Sure, this one has plenty of headscratching moments. May 30, 2015 unfortunately for blake, it hits while she is in san francisco. The martian is hitting cinemas right about now, and already it is being heralded as one of. All the science san andreas gets wrong, according to a top. In san andreas, its the science thats shaky, quake experts say. In just a few days, san andreas the movie will open nationwide. So i decided to watch the movie with a cadre of accomplished. The largest historical earthquake on the san andreas was the 1906 magnitude 7. The san andreas is strikeslip fault, in which opposing blocks of rocks slide past each other horizontally. The impression is strengthened by the careful discussions of the science of dantes peak that have been published by the usgs and the umd geology department without bothering to. As a structural engineer, it worries me slightly that a 7.
While the movie is incredibly entertaining, its also on some pretty solid ground when it comes to the science. It might not be perfect, but theres some solid truth to it. May 30, 2015 the exact likelihood of the san andreas fault triggering a series of severe earthquakes at some point in the next 30 years has been estimated to fall somewhere between 21% and 59%, calling to mind nervous memories of the 1989 earthquake which postponed game 3 of the world series at candlestick park and the 1906 san francisco quake. The new disaster movie san andreas draws on science fact that earthquakes are a reality and turns it into an action movie by creating a domino effect and pitting duane the rock johnson against them. May 28, 2015 a disaster movie starring dwayne the rock johnsonneed i say more. And serious scientist giamatti is way off base by actually predicting the monster quake on the movies san andreas fault, based on strange electromagnetic pulses he. The fault is mostly on land, and thus cannot produce a big tsunami. The coming release of dwayne johnsons movie san andreas this. Could that really happen a seismologist explores the. Can a large earthquake in nevada trigger the san andreas fault or knock down hoover dam like in the movie.
San andreas is a landbased fault, which moves along the rupture horizontally by the way, the fault would never open up as it does in the movie, leaving a gaping chasm in the ground. May 27, 2015 the san andreas fault is not long and deep enough to have a magnitude 9 or larger quake as depicted in the movie. Basically, san andreas is scientifically accurate when it can be and not accurate when the plot of the film needs something specific to happen. The special effects armageddon that is san andreas, a blockbuster starring dwayne the rock johnson, has prodded some of the states moviegoers into nervous chatter and even gasp. For those looking for some scientific accuracy to put the film into context. May 29, 2015 while youre typically supposed to refrain from texting during a movie, we find no fault in dr. Incorrect science in science fiction films insider. I dont think it is scientifically accurate, but who cares.
Whats scientifically wrong with the san andreas movie. May 25, 2015 a big san andreas quake can spark fires and other mayhem, but it cant displace water and flood san francisco. How realistic is the earthquake and tsunami depicted in. But thats why we go to the movies, and san andreas is certainly the big dumb popcorn flick to check out on the big screen this summer. Parents need to know that san andreas is a disaster movie about a huge earthquake in california. Neutrinos from a solar flare heat up the earths core, setting off the end of life as we know it. May 28, 2015 is san andreas scientifically accurate.
Jan 17, 2012 the utopian layouts and handy fasterthanlight engines of most scifi spacecraft are nowhere to be found in aliens spaceship. But some popcorn flicks are just too wrong to enjoy. San andreas is a disaster movie about a family trying to survive when the 810mile san andreas fault running through the spine of california gives way and causes massive death and destruction. Jun 01, 2015 the movie san andreas opened big in the box office this weekend, but the films overthetop depiction of the socalled big one was debunked by an expert. The long overdue, gargantuan quake leveled the metropolises along the infamous san andreas fault line. May 29, 2015 but san andreas also suggests you dont need to look like a former professional wrestler to be a hero. A big san andreas quake can spark fires and other mayhem, but it cant displace water and flood san francisco.
San andreas was released on digital hd and bluraydvd on october, 2015. But there is that pesky problem of scientific accuracy. Nov 04, 2015 while a swarm could account for the multiple quakes in the movie, the san andreas quakes have magnitudes far higher than those of usual swarm earthquakes. The movie opens tomorrow, and judging by the prerelease media, the movie is replete with scientific errors. For anyone whos scared of earthquakes particularly folks living in california, it could be a disturbing or even terrifying experience.
Find low everyday prices and buy online for delivery or instore pickup. While youre typically supposed to refrain from texting during a movie, we find no fault in dr. The exact likelihood of the san andreas fault triggering a series of severe earthquakes at some point in the next 30 years has been estimated to fall somewhere between 21% and 59%, calling to mind nervous memories of the 1989 earthquake which postponed game 3 of the world series at candlestick park and the 1906 san francisco quake. We previously published these san andreas articles. Seismologist highlights inaccuracies in upcoming san andreas. The plot conveniently ignores the fact that neutrinos pass straight.
A disaster movie starring dwayne the rock johnsonneed i say more. The usgs collected data on wave heights of the indonesia 2004 tsunami and found they varied from 15 to 30 meters. Find out if the san andreas movie is accurate as we pit science vs. The effects are great, which is most important in this kind of movie. The movie san andreas opened big in the box office this weekend, but the films overthetop depiction of the socalled big one was debunked by an expert. In san andreas, its the science thats shaky, quake. Jun 04, 2015 san andreas is a landbased fault, which moves along the rupture horizontally by the way, the fault would never open up as it does in the movie, leaving a gaping chasm in the ground. Seismologist separates fact from fiction in upcoming san. Heres everything they got wrong and right in the movie. San andreas movie page 2 the leading glock forum and.
Unfortunately for blake, it hits while she is in san francisco. Discover whether san andreas could actually happen. San andreas has some exciting moments and good special effects, with some positive christian, moral elements, but some characters are flat and some. May 29, 2015 while the san andreas movie looks so inaccurate i couldnt bear to watch it, and all your criticisms are spot on, one correction. Jun 04, 2015 the special effects armageddon that is san andreas, a blockbuster starring dwayne the rock johnson, has prodded some of the states moviegoers into nervous chatter and even gasp. Unleashing violent tremors from deep beneath the earth, the disaster triggered fires, power cuts, and the mother of all tsunamis. Lucy jones says that if you adjust the magnitudes for whats possible along the real san andreas fault, the movies triggering pattern is plausible. If you go see san andreas, it is going to be a lot of fun. With a movie like san andreas, you cant expect it to be 100% scientifically accurate. May 31, 2015 and serious scientist giamatti is way off base by actually predicting the monster quake on the movies san andreas fault, based on strange electromagnetic pulses he detects deep inside the ground. May 28, 2015 12 movies to watch after you see san andreas. Twister is arguably the most popular weather movie ever made, and it sparked an interest in meteorology in both kids and adults alike. The film stars dwayne johnson, carla gugino, alexandra daddario, ioan gruffudd, kylie minogue and paul giamatti.
Experts say there is a 99 percent chance of a magnitude6. With the aid of movie magic, the film perpetuates three big scientific inaccuracies. The san andreas fault is not long and deep enough to have a magnitude 9 or larger quake as depicted in the movie. It is a movie that was made for you to enjoy two hours of your day, so go enjoy it. San andreas is a 2015 disaster movie directed by brad peyton, starring dwayne johnson, carla gugino, alexandra daddario, kylie minogue, colton haynes, and paul giamatti the film depicts the big one, the fabled megaquake that occurs in california when the san andreas fault shifts enough to create a massive rupture. The san andreas fault is thought to be capable of only an 8. Scientists are inclined to like that their field gets in the popular consciousness by being featured in film, unless it goes too far rampant biological movie plots have led to the anti. The 10 most accurate and 10 least accurate scifi movies science fiction wouldnt be much fun if movies never took any creative license. Western nevada and eastern california occupy the walker lane that has some fault lines that are capable of up to about magnitude 7. All the science san andreas gets wrong, according to a. Heres everything they got wrong and right in the movie twister. The science behind san andreas mnn mother nature network. Still, san andreas boasts an undeniable sort of preverbal lizardbrain appeal that should make it a strong earner, especially in territories far removed from the titular fault line.
1230 319 1100 751 1483 1372 65 1528 1586 780 922 452 1230 91 1263 1595 1308 512 1086 1354 185 843 1457 976 425 366 601 531 599 645 300 932 1202 105 677 612 1116 1266 1121 773